Discussing Mergers: Making Sense of Consolidating?

Consolidating governmental services to eliminate duplication and save money makes sense when the economy is doing well, but especially so when it’s not.

As discussion heats up about consolidating services in Escambia County and the City of Pensacola, a similar debate is taking place in some states that support the nation’s historically black colleges.

In November, Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour created a firestorm when, because of declining revenues, he proposed merging Alcorn State, Jackson State and Mississippi Valley State, the state’s three historically black colleges and universities — HBCUs — into one university.

The merger would save the state $180 million, officials said.

A similar plan emerged two years ago in Georgia when a state senator proposed a merger of two of the state’s public universities with two predominately white colleges.

In the face of fierce protest, Georgia lawmakers nixed their idea. Similar opposition has arisen in Mississippi, even though Jackson State University President Ronald Mason supported the practical benefits of a merger and called for a “conversation” on the matter. The only real conversation that arose was a call for his resignation.

Even though the idea of merging HBCUs has again failed to gain traction, don’t expect the idea to go away for good.

Budget cuts aside, the debate about consolidating predominately black colleges raises questions about their purpose in the post-segregation era.

Primarily established in the South, historically black colleges and universities mostly were created in a time when equal educational opportunity was routinely denied to black people. But the question is, now that colleges have been racially integrated for decades, what exactly is the role of historically black colleges and universities?

Supporters insist that many HBCUs offers a chance of higher education to students who might not otherwise be able to get one. Historically, they graduate a higher number of the nation’s black teachers, engineers, doctors and scientists.

Others argue that the colleges are a relic of segregation that perpetuates the separation of white and black campuses, and that Southern states have more colleges than they need and can support.
Dollars and sense

Florida likely will remain out of the debate.

Florida A & M University is the only publicly supported HBCU in the state, and it has an engineering school linked with Florida State University.

But HBCUs struggling to survive, while offering similar services in close proximity to another school, can’t avoid the inevitable question of their viability.

It really boils down to dollars and sense.

When two similarly positioned companies face the same challenges for survival, they often will perform better as a combined entity than go it alone.

It’s a reality in the business world.

Since a college or university also is a business, shouldn’t it be held to a similar standard?

Screen shot 2010-02-23 at 11.00.53 PM

0 responses to “Discussing Mergers: Making Sense of Consolidating?”

  1. I’m really thankful to come across this information that I had been looking for some time. This made me pretty satisfied… This site has given us fairly helpful info. Thank you

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.